logo BDSP

Base documentaire

  1. Can experts agree when to hospitalize adolescents ?

    Article - En anglais


    Rates of psychiatric hospitalization and lengths of stay for adolescents have been a focus of recent controversy.

    With the advent of managed care, hospital systems and third-party payers are looking for ways to decide when hospitalization is indicated.

    The authors sought to determine whether experts could agree on the appropriateness of putative indicators for hospitalization of adolescents for conduct disorder or substance abuse.


    Using a methodology developed at the Rand Corporation and previously applied to procedures in medicine and surgery, the authors developed a list of possible indications for hospitalization of adolescents with conduct disorder and/or substance abuse.

    A nine-member panel of experts in these areas, balanced by geography, academics/clinical practice, and whether the expert was in charge of a hospital unit, then rated the appropriateness of each indication twice under a modified Delphi procedure.


    Using prespecified definitions for agreement, after the initial rating the panel had low levels of disagreement (11%) and moderate levels of agreement (28%) on more than 1,900 possible indications for hospitalization.

    Despite an expanded number of indications, the panel reduced disagreement to less than 5% and increased agreement to more than 55% after the second round of ratings.


    The consensus achieved compared favorably with the results of similar panels judging the appropriateness of procedures in medicine.

    Mots-clés Pascal : Prise décision, Accord, Indication, Hospitalisation, Médecin, Toxicomanie, Alcoolisme, Trouble comportement social, Adolescent, Homme, Trouble conduite, Soin coordonné

    Mots-clés Pascal anglais : Decision making, Agreement, Indication, Hospitalization, Physician, Drug addiction, Alcoholism, Social behavior disorder, Adolescent, Human

    Logo du centre Notice produite par :
    Inist-CNRS - Institut de l'Information Scientifique et Technique

    Cote : 95-0271861

    Code Inist : 002B18H05B. Création : 01/03/1996.